Discover Prospect Lefferts Gardens: A Hidden Gem in Brooklyn 2024

November 30, 2024 luigi davide 72 Views 23 min read

Prospect Lefferts Gardens stands as one of New York City’s most intriguing yet underappreciated neighborhoods, situated between Prospect Park’s eastern edge and Brooklyn’s bustling streets. The historic district showcases stunning Victorian architecture blended with vibrant Caribbean culture, creating an array of urban experiences unlike anywhere else in the city.

The neighborhood has managed to keep its authentic character while rapid changes have swept through many surrounding areas. Preserved 19th-century mansions line the tree-filled streets, sharing space with family-owned Caribbean restaurants, independent shops, and community gardens.

This detailed guide takes you through the neighborhood’s rich history, architectural heritage, cultural diversity, and modern amenities. The area’s story spans from Dutch colonial roots to its current status as an emerging cultural hub, revealing why Prospect Lefferts Gardens remains one of Brooklyn’s true hidden gems.

The Rich History Behind Prospect Lefferts Gardens

An array of cultures shaped Prospect Lefferts Gardens, starting with Dutch settlers who founded Midwout in 1652. These farmers worked the fertile lands that would later become Brooklyn ¹. This neighborhood’s story spans three centuries of American history. Waves of immigration, cultural development, and breakthroughs in architecture transformed it from rural farmland into an urban community.

From Dutch Settlement to Modern Day

The Dutch West India Company founded Midwout as one of Kings County’s six original towns. Settlers received encouragement to build “in the manner of towns, villages and hamlets as the English are in the habit of doing” ¹. British forces took control in 1664 and renamed Midwout to Flatbush, translating “Vlaake Bos” into English ¹. Dutch culture and language remained strong well into the 19th century, even under British rule.

The Lefferts Family Legacy

Leffert Pietersen van Haughwout’s arrival from Holland in 1660 marked the beginning of his family’s influence on the neighborhood ². The Lefferts soon became one of Brooklyn’s wealthiest and most influential families. Notable historical events include:

The late 17th century construction of the original Lefferts homestead
The family rebuilt their home between 1777 and 1783 after its destruction during the Revolutionary War ¹
James Lefferts divided the family estate into 600 building lots in 1893 ³

The Lefferts family’s effect on the area proved both substantial and complicated. They played a crucial role in neighborhood development but also ranked among the county’s largest slaveholding families ⁴. The 1800 census showed their household had twelve enslaved residents living with eight family members ⁴.

Rise of the Neighborhood Name

Prospect Lefferts Gardens got its current name in 1968 through the Prospect Lefferts Gardens Neighborhood Association (PLGNA) ³. This name cleverly combines the area’s three defining features: Prospect Park to the west, the historic Lefferts Manor at its heart, and the Brooklyn Botanic Gardens to the north ³.

James Lefferts changed the neighborhood’s path by creating restrictive covenants for the Lefferts Manor area. These rules required brick or stone houses with at least two stories ³. These restrictions continue today and have preserved the area’s unique architectural character. New York City recognized the neighborhood’s importance by designating it as a Landmark area in 1979 ⁵.

Architectural Treasures and Landmark Districts

Prospect Lefferts Gardens serves as proof of Brooklyn’s golden age of residential development. This neighborhood became a Historic District in 1979 ⁶. The area holds some of the finest examples of late 19th and early 20th-century urban architecture.

Victorian-Era Mansions and Brownstones

The neighborhood boasts an impressive collection of limestone and brownstone residences. Realty Associates built many of these homes between 1908 and 1912 ⁷. These neo-Renaissance style houses come with distinctive features:

Angled bay windows and foliate-adorned plaques
Original wood passthrough closets and skylights
Decorative fireplaces and pocket doors with stained glass
High ceilings with preserved parquet floors ⁸

Historic District Preservation

The Prospect Lefferts Gardens Heritage Council plays a key role in protecting the neighborhood’s architectural heritage. The organization helped expand the Lefferts Manor Historic District in 2017, which allowed building owners to access rehabilitation tax breaks ⁹. Their work continued with a proposed historic district extension in 2019 that would help over 90 more historic buildings qualify for financial assistance ⁹.

Notable Architectural Styles

The neighborhood’s architectural variety shows the changing tastes of the early 20th century. Esteemed architect Axel Hedman designed Renaissance Revival limestone homes in 1909 that feature detailed craftsmanship and unique Mediterranean roof tiles ¹⁰. Several distinctive styles define the area:

The Renaissance Revival buildings showcase superior craftsmanship with glass and iron entryways, while Romanesque Revival homes from 1910 bring different architectural elements ¹⁰. Benjamin Driesler, a busy architect of that time, designed many houses between 1908 and 1912. These were marketed as “splendid single-family homes” with stone fronts and superior fittings ⁷.

Most homes still have their original interior elements. These include beamed ceilings, wainscoting, and plate shelves typical of that period. Middle parlors often feature Craftsman-style mantels that go together with one another with built-in cabinetry. This combination has become the neighborhood’s architectural signature ⁷.

The community actively works to protect these architectural treasures. The Lefferts Manor Association hosts annual house tours that showcase nine historic houses and their gardens ¹¹. These events let visitors see the well-kept interiors of these architectural gems and learn about their historical importance.

A Cultural Melting Pot

The vibrant streets of Prospect Lefferts Gardens have resonated with Caribbean culture for more than 50 years. This Brooklyn neighborhood has evolved into one of the most culturally rich communities in the area. Recent data reveals that Black residents make up 46.9% of the population, with Caribbean-Americans playing a vital role in shaping the neighborhood’s character ¹².

Caribbean-American Influence

Caribbean culture runs deep through the community’s veins ¹³. The neighborhood pays tribute to Caribbean heroes through its street signs. Church Avenue honors musical legend Bob Marley, while Nostrand and Rogers Avenues celebrate Haitian independence leaders François-Dominique Toussaint L’Ouverture and Jean Jacques Dessalines ¹³. The area’s cultural significance earned it the official title of “Little Caribbean” in 2017 ¹³.

Cultural Festivals and Events

The community’s rich culture comes to life through year-round celebrations:

The Congo Square Drummers in Prospect Park’s Drummer’s Grove, keeping 17th-century traditions alive
Annual PLG Arts Fest showcasing free visual arts exhibitions and musical performances
Caribbean cultural celebrations that spotlight local artists and performers ¹⁴

Local Arts Scene

Creative energy flows through many initiatives and organizations in the neighborhood. PLG Arts serves as the life-blood of the community by supporting local talent and promoting artistic expression through visual arts, dance programs, and theater events ¹⁴. Local venues and BKLYN Commons regularly host the organization’s exhibitions and musical performances ¹⁵.

The PLG ABC project stands out as a remarkable artistic venture that turns public spaces into educational art displays. This initiative features 26 murals that represent the alphabet’s letters and help educate neighborhood children while adding beauty to the community ¹⁶. Building owners collaborate with local artists to create these public artworks that serve both educational and esthetic purposes.

The artistic community works hard to preserve the neighborhood’s heritage while adapting to new changes. PLG Arts co-president Rina Kleege notes that recent developments have brought new possibilities alongside challenges for cultural expression ¹⁶. The arts community strengthens connections between established residents and newcomers through its programs and initiatives. This ensures the neighborhood’s cultural legacy will thrive for generations to come.

Living in Prospect Lefferts Gardens

Prospect Lefferts Gardens blends historic charm with modern urban amenities. This unique neighborhood offers community-focused living and cultural diversity. New residents continue to move in while the area keeps its distinctive character.

Housing Options and Market Trends

Property values in Prospect Lefferts Gardens have grown remarkably. The median listing home price now stands at $1.40M ¹⁷. Current market data shows:

Median listing price per square foot: $881 ¹⁷
Average time on market: 43 days ¹⁷
Year-over-year price increase: 48.4% ¹⁸
Sale-to-list price ratio: 97.5% ¹⁷

Buyers currently have the advantage in this market, as homes typically sell slightly below asking price ¹⁷. Housing choices range from modest apartments to historic mansions, with prices starting at $199,000 and reaching up to $3.40M ¹⁷.

Schools and Education

Educational facilities in Prospect Lefferts Gardens demonstrate the area’s dedication to diverse, inclusive learning spaces. The Maple Street School, a 45-year old play-based cooperative preschool, serves children ages 2-6 ¹⁹. Their teaching approach combines the Bank Street Developmental Interaction Model with Reggio Emilia philosophies. The school prioritizes inclusive education that addresses race, gender, identity, and accessibility ¹⁹.

The neighborhood features 15 public schools rated good and higher by GreatSchools, along with 7 private and charter schools ¹⁷. Local families benefit from the zoned system most public schools use ²⁰.

Community Organizations

The Prospect Lefferts Gardens Heritage Council (PLGHC) serves as the life-blood of community development. This non-profit civic association prioritizes:

Historic building preservation
Community revitalization
Economic advancement
Cultural enhancement ⁹

The PLGHC’s achievements over the last several years include expanding the Lefferts Manor Historic District in 2017 ⁹. Their work covers educational workshops for property owners, neighborhood clean-ups, and help with property tax reduction ⁹.

Community engagement remains strong through regular meetings with block association leaders and political forums ⁹. The organization’s steadfast dedication shows in their youth mentorship programs and efforts to reduce the neighborhood’s environmental footprint ⁹.

Green Spaces and Recreation

Prospect Lefferts Gardens’ green spaces give residents a chance to enjoy outdoor recreation and join community activities. The neighborhood has everything from large parks to small community gardens that nature lovers and families can enjoy.

Proximity to Prospect Park

The neighborhood sits right next to Prospect Park, Brooklyn’s natural crown jewel that spans over 500 acres ²¹. This big urban oasis lets residents quickly reach hiking trails, biking paths, and picnic areas. The park’s eastern edge touches Prospect Lefferts Gardens and gives residents a peaceful escape from city life.

Community Gardens

The Maple Street Community Garden, a 11-year old space at 237 Maple Street, stands at the center of the neighborhood’s green initiatives ³. This community-run organic vegetable garden has grown into a vital local hub that has:

A public composting program
Fresh Food Box Program with GrowNYC ²²
Workshops about environmentally responsible gardening
Spaces where neighbors can connect with nature ²³

The garden does more than grow plants – it creates a welcoming space for everyone in the community ²³. Its focus on being available to all has made it a model for other urban community gardens.

Outdoor Activities

The neighborhood’s outdoor spaces cater to different interests and ages. The Brooklyn Botanic Garden, just steps away, shows off thousands of plants in its gardens and conservatory ²¹. Young families can join outdoor education programs where children learn through play, building vital skills like creativity and problem-solving ²⁴.

Year-round Programming has:

Educational activities for children ages 1-8
Nature-based learning initiatives
Seasonal community events and festivals

The Lefferts Historic House, run by Prospect Park Alliance and the Historic House Trust, blends history lessons with outdoor exploration. Its working garden and outdoor exhibits tell stories of resistance and resilience through hands-on experiences ²⁵.

The neighborhood’s many pocket parks and community gardens create a network of natural spaces that make it “Brooklyn’s best-kept secret” ²⁶. These green corners give people peaceful spots to relax and bring neighbors together through shared care and enjoyment.

Food Scene and Local Businesses

Prospect Lefferts Gardens boasts a rich culinary scene that mirrors its multicultural spirit. You’ll find everything from traditional Caribbean spots to modern fusion restaurants here.

Caribbean Cuisine Hotspots

This neighborhood has made its mark as a go-to spot for authentic Caribbean food. Peppa’s Jerk Chicken stands as the life-blood of local dining on Flatbush Avenue. Their cash-only setup hasn’t stopped them from becoming the neighborhood’s top spot for jerk chicken and Caribbean classics ²⁷. De Hot Pot brings Trinidadian flavors at great prices, with full meals under $10 ²⁸. Zanmi adds to the mix with genuine Haitian dishes that locals love ²⁸.

Emerging Restaurant Scene

The food scene here goes way beyond Caribbean fare. Amy Thai Bistro made history as the first Thai spot in the area, and people can’t get enough of their green curry ²⁷. Bonafini gives you that cozy Italian vibe that works great for dates or family dinners ²⁸. Taqueria El Patron brings Mexican flair with generous happy hours and free chips and salsa ²⁷.

The drink scene has grown up too. Glou Wine Bar pairs fancy wines with French-inspired small plates ²⁷. Streetsweeper Cafe and Lounge switches naturally from morning coffee spot to evening pizzeria, complete with outdoor seating ²⁸.

Shopping and Services

The retail scene keeps growing, with independent shops meeting daily needs. Awesome Brooklyn guides the shopping experience with carefully picked items ²⁹. Flatbush Avenue and nearby streets form the main shopping hub, mixing practical stores with specialty shops.

Local shops thrive on community support. Many have become neighborhood favorites through years of service. The shopping area shows off the neighborhood’s diversity with Caribbean specialty stores next to modern boutiques. This mix creates a unique shopping experience that works for both old-timers and new residents alike.

Transportation and Accessibility

Prospect Lefferts Gardens gives its residents complete public transportation choices that link this lively neighborhood to the rest of New York City. The neighborhood’s prime location and varied transit system make it a great hub that welcomes both commuters and visitors.

Subway and Bus Routes

Several transit options serve the neighborhood, and the Prospect Park station stands as a key transit center. This express station includes:

B and Q trains on weekdays
Q train and Franklin Avenue Shuttle running all day
Four-track setup with two island platforms ³⁰

The B43 bus connects Lincoln Road/Ocean Avenue to Box St/Manhattan Avenue through 53 stops ³¹. The bus service runs every 15 minutes and has kept a 68% on-time performance rating ³¹.

Commute Times to Manhattan

Your trip time to Manhattan changes based on your route and when you travel. The subway gives you these options:

Line 5 subway direct route: 37 minutes ³²
B44-SBS and B62 bus combo: about 63 minutes ³²
Line 2 and B trains alternate route: 70 minutes ³³

A subway ride between Prospect Lefferts Gardens and Manhattan costs $2.90 ³³, which works well for everyday commuters. Express services run faster during rush hours through key transfer spots at Atlantic Avenue-Barclays Center ³³.

Biking and Walking Options

Citi Bike has grown popular here with its handy bike-sharing spots around the neighborhood. Five stations dot the area around Prospect Park, giving people flexible ways to get around ³⁴. Cyclists should follow these rules:

Ride counterclockwise in marked areas
Use center lanes and pass on the right
Wear helmets if under 14
Let pedestrians go first – they have the right of way ³⁴

The neighborhood makes walking easy with its well-laid-out sidewalks and pedestrian-friendly setup. Walking paths link residents to major spots like Prospect Park and the Brooklyn Botanic Garden. Many residents can live here without needing a car.

The Prospect Park station’s ADA-compliant elevators and glass-enclosed walkways that connect to the station house ³⁰ will give a smooth ride to everyone in the community, whatever their mobility needs.

Future Development and Growth

Prospect Lefferts Gardens faces a turning point in its development. The neighborhood draws new investment while its unique character remains intact.

Real Estate Projects

New developments pop up throughout the neighborhood. The Clarkson Estates Mixed Use Project changes the area by turning a parking facility at 329 Clarkson Avenue into a multi-purpose building. This project belongs to the State of New York’s Vital Brooklyn Initiative and will add new affordable housing, retail spaces, and community facilities ³⁵.

A new eight-story building now stands where a historic wood-frame house once existed on Winthrop Street. The building offers 49 units with 27 set aside for an affordable housing lottery. Senior residents who earn between $53,589 and $111,840 yearly can apply for these units ³⁶. Residents enjoy modern features such as:

Bike storage lockers
Rooftop terrace
Package lockers
Energy-efficient utilities ³⁶

Community Initiatives

The Prospect Lefferts Gardens Heritage Council (PLGHC) runs programs that boost neighborhood life. Their recent wins include:

Educational workshops for property owners
Neighborhood clean-up initiatives
Support for residents dealing with deed fraud
Property tax reduction assistance ⁹

Block associations and community leaders meet regularly with the council to discuss neighborhood growth. They also focus on green initiatives to cut carbon footprints and reduce waste going to local landfills ⁹.

Preservation Efforts

The community embraces new development but stays dedicated to protecting its historical roots. The PLGHC helped expand the Lefferts Manor Historic District in 2017. Building owners can now get tax breaks for rehabilitation work ⁹. A proposal in 2019 sought to extend the historic district further ⁹.

The Voices of Lefferts project shows the community’s love for its local history. Residents take part in:

Recording oral histories
Writing workshops
Publishing community stories
Public readings and conversations ³⁷

Humanities New York Action Grants support this project, which partners with Greenlight Bookstore and the Brooklyn Public Library’s Brooklyn Collection to save neighborhood memories ³⁷. Volunteers work hard to capture local heritage as the area grows and changes.

The Calvert Collection shows how the neighborhood meets modern needs. This development includes a fitness center, children’s playroom, and remote work pods while keeping the area’s architectural style ³⁸.

These changes mark a fresh chapter for Prospect Lefferts Gardens. The community blends growth with preservation thoughtfully. Smart development and active community participation help keep the neighborhood’s special character alive.

Conclusion

Prospect Lefferts Gardens shows how Brooklyn knows how to keep its history alive while moving forward. This neighborhood creates a perfect mixture of Dutch colonial roots, beautiful Victorian buildings, and lively Caribbean culture. Local efforts to preserve and develop the area help keep its unique character strong for years to come.

Tree-lined streets, historic mansions, and community gardens showcase the neighborhood’s charm. Residents love their easy access to Prospect Park and great transportation options. Local groups work hard to balance growth with preservation, which makes this area perfect for people who want genuine Brooklyn living.

Prospect Lefferts Gardens means more than just another spot in Brooklyn – it shows how old and new can work together beautifully. This hidden gem grows and changes but stays true to its roots. People who want both historical character and modern city life find themselves drawn to this special place more and more.

References